Apr 18, 2021


Maori News & Indigenous Views

Tupapaku (body) of Ngati Whakaue kaumatua left in flat for 8 months – report reveals

3 min read

TangataWhenua.com was saddened to learn that a second pensioner lay dead in a Wellington council flat for at least eight months – and was found the same year as fellow tenant Michael Clarke died.

(Dominion Post) An investigation by The Dominion Post has revealed that Wiremu Whakaue died in his one-bedroom flat in Adelaide Rd in 2009, but his body was not discovered until March 2010.

Details of his death are revealed in Wellington City Council documents released to the newspaper. Just how many months he lay dead is now being investigated by the coroner.

Electricity supplier Genesis Energy confirmed yesterday that Whakaue’s power was cut off in August 2009. The Social Development Ministry, which paid Whakaue’s pension, was not advised of his death until March the following year.

The death of Clarke, whose body lay in his flat for more than a year before it was discovered, caused an outcry over the duty of care provided by the city council to its tenants.

But the council kept quiet about Whakaue’s death in similar circumstances.

Whakaue, 68, had lived for many years in flat 45 on the third floor of the dilapidated council-owned Granville Flats. Originally from Rotorua, he moved to Wellington in his 20s, family said.

Niece Susan Whakaue, of Marton, said he had been a good man.

He was a friend to everybody.” She last spoke to him about three years ago. He had been living alone, with only the occasional visitor.

The body of Clarke, 86, was found last year in his bedsit at the Newtown Park Flats. Council staff and police found old newspapers and out-of-date food, suggesting that he could have died as long ago as June 2010.

The deaths of both men are now being investigated by Wellington coroner Ian Smith. An inquest will be held on the same day in March.

Tenant Dean Stewart now lives in Whakaue’s old flat. He said he was not surprised that Whakaue’s death had gone unnoticed. “Some people have more family than they know what to do with, others have no-one.”

Nearby resident Afa Afa said people in the flats were not particularly social. “If someone died next door, I wouldn’t know. It’s a shame when people can die with no-one knowing … But I guess that’s the way with these older fellas, they like to be left alone.”

The council declined to comment on when and how it finally learned of Whakaue’s death. A spokesman said officers would have their say when they gave evidence at the inquest.

Genesis Energy said it did everything it could to contact Whakaue before it cut off his power. “We sent two reminder letters and attempted to call him by phone before the disconnection was made in August 2009. Three more invoices were sent and two reminder letters were sent in October and November 2009.”

If attempts to contact a customer were unsuccessful, a contractor would visit the property.

“Our contractors … knock on the door of the property before they commence with disconnection. If there is no response, the disconnection will go ahead.”

Any customer flagged as medically dependent would not be disconnected.” Whakaue was not flagged as medically dependent.”


Wellington City Council was given a stark warning 16 years ago about the perils of not checking on elderly tenants in its flats.

The death of an elderly man in the Newtown Park flats in 1997, whose body was not recovered for several weeks, prompted Wellington coroner Erika Kremic at the time to say: “It would not take much effort or imagination to put in place a system by which regular checks were made on people known to be living alone.”

In 1999, Wellington police called on the council to check regularly on tenants after several cases in which the bodies of elderly people were not discovered for some time.

After the discovery of Clarke’s body last year, Kremic was disappointed the council appeared not to have taken heed of her recommendations.

3 thoughts on “Tupapaku (body) of Ngati Whakaue kaumatua left in flat for 8 months – report reveals

  1. Could these terrible situations be described as ‘Indirect elder abuse’ on behalf of the council or government agencies? No sympathy seems to be given by those who ‘make out’ they have tried to prevent disconnection of electricity supply or have sent letters to an ‘overloaded letterbox’. Social policy should demand that people with authority type status should at least keep an eye on the elderly who live alone, or at least raise the level of community awareness in respect of building up a social network team designed to check up on the vulnerable. At least if the offer to support a home alone elderly person was refused, there could be no argument to suggest that no one tried. Some of the loopholes need to be addressed: If an elderly person or kaumatua has died despite deductions for rent, does the council reimburse that amount, or does the council see a ‘dead person’ occupying the rental flat as a living person for the sake of money?

  2. As the coroner said, it isn’t hard to put in place a system in which to check upon elderly tenants. Surely cues such as an overflowing letterbox are a start?

  3. How sad 2 read that the Wellington city council have let their obligations 2 their tenants and recommendations made to them continue to go without any care what so ever. Its horrific and so uncaring to know that they would allow these things to happen. They should be and feel ashamed of themselves. These people arent just a bunch of elderly nobodys!!.. Their human beings that should of been kept an eye on. Love and sympathys go out to his family. R.i.p

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.