Latest News

‘Wedge’ politics and Maori . . . | Morgan Godfrey

‘Wedge’ politics and Maori . . . | Morgan Godfrey


  • Ratings12345

(Gisborne Herald) WITH press releases like this one, Shane Jones is driving a wedge between Labour and iwi (read the Maori Party):
Iwi leaders should spend less time dreaming of ways to profit from sales of state-owned assets, and more time on salvaging the children of their tribes, says Labour’s Economic Development (Maori) spokesman Shane Jones.

“What we need are short, sharp solutions. In the absence of leadership from Dr Sharples, iwi leaders must focus on salvaging the children of their tribes instead of sucking at the teat of asset sales that won’t solve anything long term for Maori,” he said.

“In times gone by issues concerning our children were often seen as a respon-sibility for the state. Well, the state can’t solve everything. Our iwi leaders must stand up, if Dr Sharples won’t.”

As far as wedge politics goes, this is good stuff. The divide between the iwi elite, which increasingly includes the growing Maori middle class, and the Maori underclass is a source of tension in Maori politics. And Jones is siding with majority opinion on this issue. Many Maori (read the Maori underclass) resent the fact that wealth from Treaty settlements has not “trickled down”.

I’ve said before, many iwi take a top-down approach to distributing income. For example, tribal executives are paid handsomely, a tribe’s tertiary students receive decent financial support and kaumatua and kuia often receive financial support too. However, those on the bottom of Maori society — for example, single parents — receive no support. This approach serves to perpetuate the privileged position of the Maori elite.

The largest source of tension is, in my opinion, the priorities of those Maori elite. Some iwi leaders are enthusiastically pursuing asset sales. However, Maori overwhelmingly oppose asset sales.

Many in the Maori elite also seem more concerned about maintaining their power and pay cheques than serving their people.

The prevailing feeling is that iwi should be looking at investing more heavily in their people rather than fretting about their bottom lines. This is an idea I sympathise with, but do not agree with. Social services are the responsibility of government. Iwi have a social obligation, no doubt about that, but iwi do not have the means to offer social services.

Firstly, iwi do not have the economy of scales, but most importantly, iwi are not self sufficient. In other words, iwi cannot fund social services out of their pockets unless, of course, they pay more attention to growing their bottom line.

It’s a bit of a paradox. Sure, if Maori were paying taxes to iwi, then iwi have a social and moral imperative to fund and deliver social services. This, however, is not and never will be the case.

Anyway, back to the politics of this issue. Jones is siding with the Maori underclass here and painting the Maori Party into a corner . . . a corner with the Maori elite. It will be interesting to see how Jones plays this. I would expect to see him cultivate tensions further.

With any luck, this will lead Maori to have a debate during which they can ask questions like “Do iwi have their priorities right?” “What is the role of iwi in contemporary Maori society?” And “are Treaty settlements creating a Maori elite?”

To be honest, I don’t like the use of wedge politics in Maori politics, but this is a debate Maori need to have.

Morgan Godfrey is a Wellington-based law student and regular commentator for the Gisborne Herald on Maori politics.

(5) Comments

  1. Hud Rapata

    Hi Morgan I take no notice of Jones at any given time , however this will play right into his hands.Weather or not Iwi receive taxes or not, their first priority is to the hapu and whanau. Time to stop this bullshit and make these Iwi accountable, they are out of control. Mauri Ora

  2. Hud Rapata

    Hi Morgan I take no notice of Jones at any given time , however his will play right into his hands.Weather or not Iwi receive taxes or not, their first priority is to the hapu and whanau. Time to stop this bullshit and make these Iwi accountable, they are out of control. Mauri Ora

  3. Lily

    I agree with many of Shane's comments. I don't like the man - but he's on the nail in some part. Particularly in how assets are negotiated for and the use of them thereafter for whanau utilisation. Respectfully, Morgan - I disagree with some of your comments. IWI do have economy of scale and the opportunities to develop community microeconomies have never been more opportunistic.

  4. Mana Rongomaiwahine o Mahia

    2 meke mahi Morgan,So glad to be living in this era wif prophesy of fore father taking place.Each day I strive and contribute whatever way to help.somedays very rewarding nix min 1 step forward 10 steps back.My whanau o Ngai Tu Te Rakato work as HAPU and always acknowledge our other hapu in te rohe of Rongomaiwahine.Mana whenua is life to our hapu and we will never disconnect ourselves from Papatuanuku and Ranginui.We are so rich in taonga why can't we have our own "MONEY".In my life span I have bein able to spend the "Pound Shilling & Pence" now the "Dollars and Cents" sung "God Save the Queen" now "God Defend N.Z"..I do love our "Maori Anthem & Haka".I had to opportunity to attend Kowhiri in Gisborne and witnessed to whole scene of politics wif our Ikaroa-Rawhiti candidates.The harmony and spirit heard and felt in the hall was so wonderful to be unified in waiata THEN nix min Julian Wilcox'z turns it into a best favorite of three Maori Men and their Warriors.I told Shane Jones after the bebate that "POLITICS SUXS" and thats where the diversion of our people begin.Mana is Pride,Mana Whenua is Life, MaURI Ora!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Latest Tweets

  • DigitalMaorianei na whaea Annette http://t.co/gYxQOt47Co about 12 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriaue... @tautokai about 12 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @BrianBoruNZ: @DigitalMaori @runningwhio @tautokai @LewSOS Greens in Otepoti are heavily involved in social/envmntal actions together wi… about 13 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@tautokai @runningwhio well if I can be so bold, what new combined actions could you see Greens and Mana working together on? about 13 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@caffeine_addict hahaha that's the one! about 13 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@tautokai @runningwhio we hear that only a combined left can beat National yet see no combined effort. Potentials there. Just need action. about 13 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@caffeine_addict isn't that the guy who voted with middle NZ on foreshore seabed, forgot he was Maori and got booted out? Oh yea, him... about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@tautokai @runningwhio I'm Mana party hard & often hear 'the left' need to work together but usually only see our members doing the yards about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @nzmusicmonth: Country Album & Song Finalists Announced http://t.co/v6WEEUmWCJ about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@runningwhio @tautokai @LewSOS agree. We attended loads of rally's demos community actions in 2013 & 2015 and few to no Greens attended about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @deltablues_king: Interested to know if @stevenljoyce has a decent comeback to this #epicburn by @TheBubbleBubble ? #nzpol http://t.co/8… about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@runningwhio @tautokai @LewSOS @buzzandhum @MorganGodfery interesting, as most of the Maori issues we followed in 2013 had few Green voices about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @reomaori: He kaupapa o te wā: te whakawāteatanga o tērā o tātou i tana tūranga. Ētahi wā, ka tuhia e mātou he kaupapa o te wā ki tō tāt… about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@althecat @winstonpeters @matuashane This is like wrestling, when the fan fave turns into the heel, then redeems himself and returns about 14 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@MorganGodfery despite being a 'great orator' we struggled to find anything useful he contributed. Shane fought for Shane, not Maori. about 15 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@MaramaDavidson kao nothing certain just whispers. We thought Manu Caddie would be perfect then he resigned from council. about 19 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@MaramaDavidson definitely optimistic about 19 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@MaramaDavidson those 4 MPs = 60 years lost experience. A few more could announce their departure before Sept 20. Succession looks urgent. about 19 hours ago
  • DigitalMaori@MaramaDavidson I'm interested in which party will include engage & encourage 18 - 21yr old candidates. 40yr old 'rangatahi' make me laugh about 20 hours ago
  • DigitalMaoriIs a bit worried that Maori are losing Tau, Tariana, Pita and now Shane from Parliament in quick succession #nextcab #thinline about 20 hours ago