Latest News

Chief Justice’s views give hope to Maori

20130202-130009.jpg

(Adam Bennett, NZ Herald) The sale of power company shares would “inevitably” create barriers to the Government’s ability to provide redress for Maori rights, Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias said yesterday.

Her comments during the Supreme Court hearing of the Maori Council’s final bid to halt the Mighty River Power sale later this year have heartened the council, whose case was comprehensively rejected by Justice Ronald Young in the High Court late last year.

At the heart of the council’s case is the claim that the sale of up to 49 per cent of shares in Mighty River Power and other hydro and geothermal electricity generators will compromise the Government’s ability to compensate for any successful Maori freshwater claims.

In the hearing before Dame Sian, Justice Sir John McGrath, Justice Sir William Young, Justice Robert Chambers and Justice Susan Glazebrook, David Goddard, QC, yesterday detailed the reasoning behind the Crown’s view that the sale of shares would not affect its ability to make redress.

Mr Goddard said the Crown had conducted “extensive consultation” with Maori over the “shares plus” suggestion made by the Waitangi Tribunal which would give Maori shares in the power companies with additional decision-making rights as a possible means of redress.

Neither the Government nor Maori were positive about that suggestion and it was abandoned, but the consultation also sought alternative suggestions.

Mr Goddard said the council had failed to identify an alternative which showed “all forms of rights recognition and redress which are meaningful which respond to the claims made remain on the table and are not materially affected as to the availability or likelihood by the proposed partial share sales”.

But Dame Sian herself had raised possible alternatives during the hearing. She said the court was “interested in practical steps that could be taken” to protect future settlements “because that may reflect on whether the Crown is actually in conformity” with provisions in the State Owned Enterprises Act and the new Mixed Ownership Model Act that set out the Government’s Treaty obligations.

She observed that many Waitangi water claims had been around for a long time without resolution “and while issues such as ownership or proprietary interests are parked, more and more interests affecting third parties arise which must inevitably provide an impediment to direct response”.

Colin Carruthers, QC, for the Maori Council said that the Crown would face “an obvious and significant impairment” in any attempt to involve Maori in the exploitation of the rivers following the sale of shares to “thousands of mums and dads”.

Maori Council lawyer Donna Hall said the court appeared to be more willing to listen to the council’s arguments with an open mind than the High Court’s Justice Young had been.

She said the proposition that the sale of shares to private investors would affect the Crown’s ability to provide redress was “a matter of practical reality”.

The Government hopes to receive the court’s decision before February 18 in order to meet its timetable to sell Mighty River shares before June.

Latest Tweets

  • DigitalMaoriRT @InternetPartyNZ: The #IntenretMANA roadtrip comes to #Taupo tomorrow, 6pm at Taupo-nui-a-Tia College, 122 Spa Rd.Come and see the tour … about 6 minutes ago
  • DigitalMaori@caffeine_addict totally about 44 minutes ago
  • DigitalMaori@koreroauaha totally biased towards those who have .75 to pay a pop about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @giaisonline: BREAKING: John Key is not a political commentator #Vote2014NZ about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @DawgBelly: Cunliffe looked fresh, Key looked like a grizzled lying dog scrotum, but that's just my humble completely unbiased opinion. about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @bossology_: anyone who actually watched the debate knows that poll was completel bullshit LOL #LeadersDebate #Vote2014NZ #nzpol about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @CrikaRika: John Key wins a poll where you have to PAY FOR A TEXT lol #Vote2014NZ about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaori@MTONeill @Serentonin nope not one #factcheck ;p about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @MTONeill: Did JK answer one question in that debate? #Vote2014NZ about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @kaupapa: mass WTF at spurious poll result about debate #greenroomnz about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @WillAMatthews: Oh yeah like that fucking poll is definitely scientifically accurate. about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @E2NZ: RT if you think Cunliffe won the #LeadersDebate roll rigged? about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @citizen_henry: @johnkeypm #notmyfuture #Vote2014NZ about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @LewSOS: BREAKING: people willing to pay 75c to participate in a meaningless text poll like John Key about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @Nick_dee88: i often mistake @hoskingonzb for @Whaleoil #LeadersDebate about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaori@2TAPU love ur rangatahi's insights! about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @2TAPU: Mister Cunliffe looks like he goes outside a lot more than Mister Key he is browner - 12YO #leadersdebate about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @2TAPU: @Kiwiseabreeze LOL #leadersdebate 12yo says they haven't talked about smacking kids yet (his major issue) about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @carol_stirling: John key won! Bullshit! about an hour ago
  • DigitalMaoriRT @AP: Woman's quest to ID about 600 people buried in Arizona Indian cemetery teaches her about Native culture: http://t.co/3AQFtcu2pY about an hour ago