May 12, 2021

Maori News & Indigenous Views

Everyone wins through greater consultation, David Taipari, NZHerald

3 min read

The Independent Maori Statutory Board is determined to make a positive contribution for all Maori and everyone else in the Auckland region. We’ve developed a work programme and are keen to get it under way.

We’re very aware that our arrival has been controversial.

The Royal Commission recommended the new council have two elected Maori seats and one appointed by tangata whenua. After the Government rejected this, with some arguing there should be no statutory Maori representation, the board was a compromise first proposed in a Cabinet paper by Local Government Minister Rodney Hide and Maori Affairs Minister Pita Sharples in August 2009.

After being adopted by Cabinet, Mr Hide introduced legislation in December 2009 to establish the board and outline its role and obligations.

The legislation was not rushed, but was scrutinised for five months by the Auckland Governance Legislation Select Committee, including representation from the National, Labour, Maori, Green and Act parties.

When it came to the board, the select committee made no major changes to Mr Hide’s legislation.

The legislation, finally passed by Parliament in June 2010, is prescriptive. It uses the word “must” a lot and leaves little room for doubt or confusion.

It says the board must be appointed by a process facilitated by the Maori Affairs Minister and involving all Auckland Maori. The nine members of the board were announced by Dr Sharples on October 29.

The legislation says our purpose is to promote cultural, economic, environmental and social issues of significance to Maori in Auckland and to ensure the council acts in accordance with statutory provisions referring to the Treaty of Waitangi.

The law is clear we must be independent from the Auckland Council . We must identify issues of importance to Maori, work with the council and give advice on how it should implement its statutory Treaty obligations.

We must appoint up to two people as members of every council committee that deals with the management and stewardship of natural and physical resources. We have no representation or votes on the council proper.

To do our job, the law says we should consult those who can help us achieve our purpose and seek external advice.

We are required to put together a budget to carry out these statutory obligations and reach agreement with the council by February 15 on our funding. The law says the council must meet the reasonable costs of our operations, secretariat and external advisers to enable us to carry out our statutory obligations.

The board has followed the law to the letter and has been working with council officers and an independent consultant since mid-December to ensure costs would be reasonable.

After a workshop between councillors and board members last Monday, the council’s strategy and finance committee, which includes all councillors, unanimously agreed our budget last Tuesday.

Some councillors changed their minds six days later and it seems we will now need to ask the courts to consider the matter. Hopefully, the mayor joins us in making that application.

When this matter is resolved, the board’s first initiative will be to commission an audit of all local government spending on Maori engagement and consultation in the Auckland region over the last five years.

The objective of the audit will be to identify savings and do a better job in engaging and consulting Maori. It is designed to be win/win for all ratepayers and all Maori.

The audit will also provide a baseline in terms of spending and efficacy so our performance in delivering savings and improving quality can be measured down the line.

Depending on how long it takes to resolve present budget issues, we would like the audit to be completed by the middle of the year.

The substantive part of our work programme will then be able to begin in earnest and will be looking at initiatives on everything from opening up new life opportunities for disadvantaged Maori, to fostering Maori enterprise, to a longer list of specific initiatives that nag local communities.

Not everyone is happy about the existence of the board, our voting on subcommittees, our role or our budget.

It is our job to earn the trust of all Maori, our council colleagues and all Aucklanders. Kia kotahi tatou katoa o Tamaki. We are all Aucklanders. We all have an interest in making the new council work.

– David Taipari is chairman of the Independent Maori Statutory Board for Auckland.

3 thoughts on “Everyone wins through greater consultation, David Taipari, NZHerald

  1. Court action about 'clarification, not confrontation' – Taipari

    Tue, 15 Feb 2011 1:35p.m.

    The Auckland Maori Board is to press ahead with court action against the Auckland Council for slashing its 2011/2012 budget in a close decision last night.

    The board’s chair, David Taipari today said the legal action is about “clarification, not confrontation”.

    The board is talking to lawyers and writing to the council after the governing body decided to cut the board’s budget from $3.4 million to $1.9 million.

    Mr Taipari, who was appointed by Mayor Len Brown in November, said there was no evidence to show the budget was unreasonable.

    Legislation setting up the board was quite clear and the council had to meet the reasonable costs of the board's operations, secretariat and independent advisers, he said.

    The board believed if proposed costs were reasonable, the council had no discretion and last night's decision on funding was probably breached the law.

    Mr Taipari said the board had taken significant steps to ensure its costs were reasonable, had sought the help of an independent consultant and had worked with council officers to identify a reasonable level of funding. The council's finance committee had also unanimously agreed last week on the funding.

    Mayor Len Brown said the board was entitled to seek a declaratory judgment, which normally was dealt with quickly.

    The council also voted to ask the Government to clarify the intentions of its legislation.


  2. Forum set up to tackle Auckland's social issues

    A new forum has been set up to tackle social issues in Auckland.

    The forum will be co-chaired by Social Development Minister Paula Bennett and Mayor Len Brown.

    It will also include representatives from local boards, the Maori Statutory Board, Pacific and Ethnic Peoples Advisory Panels, Youth Advisory Panel and 10 community representatives.

    Auckland Council member Ann Hartley said the forum will focus on protecting children, employment and family violence.

    She said the object is for the council and the government to work together to ensure maximum effectiveness.

  3. Sharples reprimanded over criticism of Hide

    17/02/2011 5:28:00

    Prime Minister John Key says Maori Affairs Minister Dr Pita Sharples should not have made the statement calling for Local Government Minister Rodney Hide to resign

    Pita Sharples has been reprimanded over his criticism of Local Government Minister Rodney Hide.

    He did so in his capacity as Maori Affairs Minister, calling on Mr Hide to resign over the controversy involving the Auckland Council's Maori Statutory Board.

    The Prime Minister says Dr Sharples shouldn't have made the statement under his ministerial letterhead.

    John Key says his office has been reminded of the rules governing cabinet decisions.

    Meanwhile, Rodney Hide's got away with his criticisms of Dr Sharples because he did it in his capacity as ACT leader, not Local Government Minister.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.